ViewVC Help
View File | Revision Log | Show Annotations | View Changeset | Root Listing
root/group/trunk/tengDissertation/LiquidCrystal.tex
(Generate patch)

Comparing trunk/tengDissertation/LiquidCrystal.tex (file contents):
Revision 2784 by tim, Thu Jun 1 20:14:11 2006 UTC vs.
Revision 2938 by tim, Mon Jul 17 15:28:44 2006 UTC

# Line 2 | Line 2 | Long range orientational order is one of the most fund
2  
3   \section{\label{liquidCrystalSection:introduction}Introduction}
4  
5 < Long range orientational order is one of the most fundamental
6 < properties of liquid crystal mesophases. This orientational
7 < anisotropy of the macroscopic phases originates in the shape
8 < anisotropy of the constituent molecules. Among these anisotropy
9 < mesogens, rod-like (calamitic) and disk-like molecules have been
10 < exploited in great detail in the last two decades. Typically, these
11 < mesogens consist of a rigid aromatic core and one or more attached
12 < aliphatic chains. For short chain molecules, only nematic phases, in
13 < which positional order is limited or absent, can be observed,
14 < because the entropy of mixing different parts of the mesogens is
15 < paramount to the dispersion interaction. In contrast, formation of
16 < the one dimension lamellar sematic phase in rod-like molecules with
17 < sufficiently long aliphatic chains has been reported, as well as the
18 < segregation phenomena in disk-like molecules.
5 > Rod-like (calamitic) and disk-like anisotropy liquid crystals have
6 > been investigated in great detail in the last two
7 > decades\cite{Huh2004}. Typically, these mesogens consist of a rigid
8 > aromatic core and one or more attached aliphatic chains. For short
9 > chain molecules, only nematic phases, in which positional order is
10 > limited or absent, can be observed, because the entropy of mixing
11 > different parts of the mesogens is larger than the dispersion
12 > interaction. In contrast, formation of one dimension lamellar
13 > smectic phase in rod-like molecules with sufficiently long aliphatic
14 > chains has been reported, as well as the segregation phenomena in
15 > disk-like molecules\cite{McMillan1971}. Recently, banana-shaped or
16 > bent-core liquid crystals have became one of the most active
17 > research areas in mesogenic materials and supramolecular
18 > chemistry\cite{Niori1996, Link1997, Pelzl1999}. Unlike rods and
19 > disks, the polarity and biaxiality of the banana-shaped molecules
20 > allow the molecules organize into a variety of novel liquid
21 > crystalline phases which show interesting material properties. Of
22 > particular interest is the spontaneous formation of macroscopic
23 > chiral layers from achiral banana-shaped molecules, where polar
24 > molecule orientational ordering exhibited layered plane as well as
25 > the tilted arrangement of the molecules relative to the polar axis.
26 > As a consequence of supramolecular chirality, the spontaneous
27 > polarization arises in ferroelectric (FE) and antiferroelectic (AF)
28 > switching of smectic liquid crystal phases, demonstrating some
29 > promising applications in second-order nonlinear optical devices.
30 > The most widely investigated mesophase formed by banana-shaped
31 > moleculed is the $\text{B}_2$ phase, which is also referred to as
32 > $\text{SmCP}$\cite{Link1997}. Of the most important discoveries in
33 > this tilt lamellar phase is the four distinct packing arrangements
34 > (two conglomerates and two macroscopic racemates), which depend on
35 > the tilt direction and the polar direction of the molecule in
36 > adjacent layer (see Fig.~\ref{LCFig:SMCP})\cite{Link1997}.
37  
20 Recently, the banana-shaped or bent-core liquid crystal have became
21 one of the most active research areas in mesogenic materials and
22 supramolecular chemistry. Unlike rods and disks, the polarity and
23 biaxiality of the banana-shaped molecules allow the molecules
24 organize into a variety of novel liquid crystalline phases which
25 show interesting material properties. Of particular interest is the
26 spontaneous formation of macroscopic chiral layers from achiral
27 banana-shaped molecules, where polar molecule orientational ordering
28 is shown within the layer plane as well as the tilted arrangement of
29 the molecules relative to the polar axis. As a consequence of
30 supramolecular chirality, the spontaneous polarization arises in
31 ferroelectric (FE) and antiferroelectic (AF) switching of smectic
32 liquid crystal phases, demonstrating some promising applications in
33 second-order nonlinear optical devices. The most widely investigated
34 mesophase formed by banana-shaped moleculed is the $\text{B}_2$
35 phase, which is also referred to as $\text{SmCP}$. Of the most
36 important discover in this tilt lamellar phase is the four distinct
37 packing arrangements (two conglomerates and two macroscopic
38 racemates), which depend on the tilt direction and the polar
39 direction of the molecule in adjacent layer (see
40 Fig.~\cite{LCFig:SMCP}).
41
38   \begin{figure}
39   \centering
40   \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{smcp.eps}
41 < \caption[]
42 < {}
41 > \caption[SmCP Phase Packing] {Four possible SmCP phase packings that
42 > are characterized by the relative tilt direction(A and S refer an
43 > anticlinic tilt or a synclinic ) and the polarization orientation (A
44 > and F represent antiferroelectric or ferroelectric polar order).}
45   \label{LCFig:SMCP}
46   \end{figure}
47  
48   Many liquid crystal synthesis experiments suggest that the
49   occurrence of polarity and chirality strongly relies on the
50 < molecular structure and intermolecular interaction. From a
51 < theoretical point of view, it is of fundamental interest to study
52 < the structural properties of liquid crystal phases formed by
50 > molecular structure and intermolecular interaction\cite{Reddy2006}.
51 > From a theoretical point of view, it is of fundamental interest to
52 > study the structural properties of liquid crystal phases formed by
53   banana-shaped molecules and understand their connection to the
54   molecular structure, especially with respect to the spontaneous
55   achiral symmetry breaking. As a complementary tool to experiment,
# Line 62 | Line 60 | limitation of time scale required for phase
60   smectic arrangements\cite{Cook2000, Lansac2001}, as well as other
61   bulk properties, such as rotational viscosity and flexoelectric
62   coefficients\cite{Cheung2002, Cheung2004}. However, due to the
63 < limitation of time scale required for phase
64 < transition\cite{Wilson1999} and the length scale required for
65 < representing bulk behavior, the dominant models in the field of
66 < liquid crystal phase behavior are generic
67 < models\cite{Lebwohl1972,Perram1984, Gay1981}, which are based on the
68 < observation that liquid crystal order is exhibited by a range of
69 < non-molecular bodies with high shape anisotropies. Previous
70 < simulation studies using hard spherocylinder dimer
71 < model\cite{Camp1999} produce nematic phases, while hard rod
72 < simulation studies identified a Landau point\cite{Bates2005}, at
73 < which the isotropic phase undergoes a direct transition to the
74 < biaxial nematic, as well as some possible liquid crystal
75 < phases\cite{Lansac2003}. Other anisotropic models using
78 < Gay-Berne(GB) potential, which produce interactions that favor local
79 < alignment, give the evidence of the novel packing arrangements of
80 < bent-core molecules\cite{Memmer2002,Orlandi2006}.
63 > limitation of time scales required for phase transition and the
64 > length scale required for representing bulk behavior,
65 > models\cite{Perram1985, Gay1981}, which are based on the observation
66 > that liquid crystal order is exhibited by a range of non-molecular
67 > bodies with high shape anisotropies, have become the dominant models
68 > in the field of liquid crystal phase behavior. Previous simulation
69 > studies using a hard spherocylinder dimer model\cite{Camp1999}
70 > produced nematic phases, while hard rod simulation studies
71 > identified a direct transition to the biaxial nematic and other
72 > possible liquid crystal phases\cite{Lansac2003}. Other anisotropic
73 > models using the Gay-Berne(GB) potential, which produces
74 > interactions that favor local alignment, give evidence of the novel
75 > packing arrangements of bent-core molecules\cite{Memmer2002}.
76  
77   Experimental studies by Levelut {\it et al.}~\cite{Levelut1981}
78   revealed that terminal cyano or nitro groups usually induce
79   permanent longitudinal dipole moments, which affect the phase
80 < behavior considerably. A series of theoretical studies also drawn
81 < equivalent conclusions. Monte Carlo studies of the GB potential with
82 < fixed longitudinal dipoles (i.e. pointed along the principal axis of
83 < rotation) were shown to enhance smectic phase
80 > behavior considerably. Equivalent conclusions have also been drawn
81 > from a series of theoretical studies. Monte Carlo studies of the GB
82 > potential with fixed longitudinal dipoles (i.e. pointed along the
83 > principal axis of rotation) were shown to enhance smectic phase
84   stability~\cite{Berardi1996,Satoh1996}. Molecular simulation of GB
85   ellipsoids with transverse dipoles at the terminus of the molecule
86   also demonstrated that partial striped bilayer structures were
# Line 98 | Line 93 | In this chapter, we consider system consisting of bana
93   bent-core molecules, could be modeled more accurately by
94   incorporating electrostatic interaction.
95  
96 < In this chapter, we consider system consisting of banana-shaped
97 < molecule represented by three rigid GB particles with one or two
98 < point dipoles at different location. Performing a series of
99 < molecular dynamics simulations, we explore the structural properties
100 < of tilted smectic phases as well as the effect of electrostatic
106 < interactions.
96 > In this chapter, we consider a system consisting of banana-shaped
97 > molecule represented by three rigid GB particles with two point
98 > dipoles. Performing a series of molecular dynamics simulations, we
99 > explore the structural properties of tilted smectic phases as well
100 > as the effect of electrostatic interactions.
101  
102   \section{\label{liquidCrystalSection:model}Model}
103  
# Line 116 | Line 110 | orientation and position dependent range ($\sigma$) an
110   potential used to mimic the apolar characteristics of liquid crystal
111   molecules takes the familiar form of Lennard-Jones function with
112   orientation and position dependent range ($\sigma$) and well depth
113 < ($\epsilon$) parameters. It can can be expressed as,
113 > ($\epsilon$) parameters. The potential between a pair of three-site
114 > banana-shaped molecules $a$ and $b$ is given by
115   \begin{equation}
116 + V_{ab}^{GB}  = \sum\limits_{i \in a,j \in b} {V_{ij}^{GB} }.
117 + \end{equation}
118 + Every site-site interaction can can be expressed as,
119 + \begin{equation}
120   V_{ij}^{GB}  = 4\epsilon (\hat u_i ,\hat u_j ,\hat r_{ij} )\left[
121   {\left( {\frac{{\sigma _0 }}{{r_{ij}  - \sigma (\hat u_i ,\hat u_j
122   ,\hat r_{ij} )}}} \right)^{12}  - \left( {\frac{{\sigma _0
# Line 125 | Line 124 | orientation of two molecules $i$ and $j$ separated by
124   } \right] \label{LCEquation:gb}
125   \end{equation}
126   where $\hat u_i,\hat u_j$ are unit vectors specifying the
127 < orientation of two molecules $i$ and $j$ separated by intermolecular
128 < vector $r_{ij}$. $\hat r_{ij}$ is the unit vector along the
129 < intermolecular vector. A schematic diagram of the orientation
130 < vectors is shown in Fig.\ref{LCFigure:GBScheme}. The functional form
131 < for $\sigma$ is given by
127 > orientation of two ellipsoids $i$ and $j$ separated by
128 > intermolecular vector $r_{ij}$. $\hat r_{ij}$ is the unit vector
129 > along the inter-ellipsoid vector. A schematic diagram of the
130 > orientation vectors is shown in Fig.\ref{LCFigure:GBScheme}. The
131 > functional form for $\sigma$ is given by
132   \begin{equation}
133   \sigma (\hat u_i ,\hat u_i ,\hat r_{ij} ) = \sigma _0 \left[ {1 -
134   \frac{\chi }{2}\left( {\frac{{(\hat r_{ij}  \cdot \hat u_i  + \hat
# Line 146 | Line 145 | and the end-to-end length of the ellipsoid, respective
145   \label{LCEquation:chi}
146   \end{equation}
147   Here, $\sigma_ s$ and $\sigma_{e}$ refer to the side-by-side breadth
148 < and the end-to-end length of the ellipsoid, respectively. Twell
148 > and the end-to-end length of the ellipsoid, respectively. The well
149   depth parameters takes the form
150   \begin{equation}
151   \epsilon (\hat u_i ,\hat u_j ,\hat r_{ij} ) = \epsilon _0 \epsilon
# Line 169 | Line 168 | ratio between \textit{end-to-end} well depth $\epsilon
168   where the well depth anisotropy parameter $\chi '$ depends on the
169   ratio between \textit{end-to-end} well depth $\epsilon _e$ and
170   \textit{side-by-side} well depth $\epsilon_s$,
171 < \begin{eqaution}
171 > \begin{equation}
172   \chi ' = \frac{{1 - (\epsilon _e /\epsilon _s )^{1/\mu} }}{{1 +
173   (\epsilon _e /\epsilon _s )^{1/\mu} }}.
174   \end{equation}
# Line 177 | Line 176 | ratio between \textit{end-to-end} well depth $\epsilon
176   \begin{figure}
177   \centering
178   \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{banana.eps}
179 < \caption[]{} \label{LCFig:BananaMolecule}
179 > \caption[Schematic representation of a typical banana shaped
180 > molecule]{Schematic representation of a typical banana shaped
181 > molecule.} \label{LCFig:BananaMolecule}
182   \end{figure}
183 + \begin{figure}
184 + \centering
185 + \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{gb_scheme.eps}
186 + \caption[Schematic diagram showing definitions of the orientation
187 + vectors for a pair of Gay-Berne molecules]{Schematic diagram showing
188 + definitions of the orientation vectors for a pair of Gay-Berne
189 + ellipsoids} \label{LCFigure:GBScheme}
190 + \end{figure}
191 + To account for the permanent dipolar interactions, there should be
192 + an electrostatic interaction term of the form
193 + \begin{equation}
194 + V_{ab}^{dp}  = \sum\limits_{i \in a,j \in b} {\frac{1}{{4\pi
195 + \epsilon _{fs} }}\left[ {\frac{{\mu _i  \cdot \mu _j }}{{r_{ij}^3 }}
196 + - \frac{{3\left( {\mu _i  \cdot r_{ij} } \right)\left( {\mu _i \cdot
197 + r_{ij} } \right)}}{{r_{ij}^5 }}} \right]}
198 + \end{equation}
199 + where $\epsilon _{fs}$ is the permittivity of free space.
200  
201 + \section{Results and Discussion}
202 +
203 + A series of molecular dynamics simulations were performed to study the
204 + phase behavior of banana shaped liquid crystals. In each simulation,
205 + every banana shaped molecule has been represented by three GB
206 + particles which is characterized by $\mu = 1,~ \nu = 2,
207 + ~\epsilon_{e}/\epsilon_{s} = 1/5$ and $\sigma_{e}/\sigma_{s} = 3$.
208 + All of the simulations begin with same equilibrated isotropic
209 + configuration where 1024 molecules without dipoles were confined in
210 + a $160\times 160 \times 120$ box. After the dipolar interactions are
211 + switched on, 2~ns NPTi cooling run with themostat of 2~ps and
212 + barostat of 50~ps were used to equilibrate the system to desired
213 + temperature and pressure. NPTi Production runs last for 40~ns with
214 + time step of 20~fs.
215 +
216 + \subsection{Order Parameters}
217 +
218 + To investigate the phase structure of the model liquid crystal, we
219 + calculated various order parameters and correlation functions.
220 + Particulary, the $P_2$ order parameter allows us to estimate average
221 + alignment along the director axis $Z$ which can be identified from
222 + the largest eigenvalue obtained by diagonalizing the order parameter
223 + tensor
224 + \begin{equation}
225 + \overleftrightarrow{\mathsf{Q}} = \frac{1}{N}\sum_i^N %
226 +    \begin{pmatrix} %
227 +    u_{ix}u_{ix}-\frac{1}{3} & u_{ix}u_{iy} & u_{ix}u_{iz} \\
228 +    u_{iy}u_{ix} & u_{iy}u_{iy}-\frac{1}{3} & u_{iy}u_{iz} \\
229 +    u_{iz}u_{ix} & u_{iz}u_{iy} & u_{iz}u_{iz}-\frac{1}{3} %
230 +    \end{pmatrix},
231 + \label{lipidEq:p2}
232 + \end{equation}
233 + where the $u_{i\alpha}$ is the $\alpha$ element of the unit vector
234 + $\mathbf{\hat{u}}_i$, and the sum over $i$ averages over the whole
235 + collection of unit vectors. The $P_2$ order parameter for uniaxial
236 + phase is then simply given by
237 + \begin{equation}
238 + \langle P_2 \rangle = \frac{3}{2}\lambda_{\text{max}}.
239 + \label{lipidEq:po3}
240 + \end{equation}
241 + %In addition to the $P_2$ order parameter, $ R_{2,2}^2$ order
242 + %parameter for biaxial phase is introduced to describe the ordering
243 + %in the plane orthogonal to the director by
244 + %\begin{equation}
245 + %R_{2,2}^2  = \frac{1}{4}\left\langle {(x_i  \cdot X)^2  - (x_i \cdot
246 + %Y)^2  - (y_i  \cdot X)^2  + (y_i  \cdot Y)^2 } \right\rangle
247 + %\end{equation}
248 + %where $X$, $Y$ and $Z$ are axis of the director frame.
249 + The unit vector for the banana shaped molecule was defined by the
250 + principle aixs of its middle GB particle. The $P_2$ order parameters
251 + for the bent-core liquid crystal at different temperature are
252 + summarized in Table~\ref{liquidCrystal:p2} which identifies a phase
253 + transition temperature range.
254 +
255 + \begin{table}
256 + \caption{LIQUID CRYSTAL STRUCTURAL PROPERTIES AS A FUNCTION OF
257 + TEMPERATURE} \label{liquidCrystal:p2}
258 + \begin{center}
259 + \begin{tabular}{cccccc}
260 + \hline
261 + Temperature (K) & 420 & 440 & 460 & 480 & 600\\
262 + \hline
263 + $\langle P_2\rangle$ & 0.984 & 0.982 & 0.975 & 0.967 & 0.067\\
264 + \hline
265 + \end{tabular}
266 + \end{center}
267 + \end{table}
268 +
269 + \subsection{Structural Properties}
270 +
271 + The molecular organization obtained at temperature $T = 460K$ (below
272 + transition temperature) is shown in Figure~\ref{LCFigure:snapshot}.
273 + The diagonal view in Fig~\ref{LCFigure:snapshot}(a) shows the
274 + stacking of the banana shaped molecules while the side view in
275 + Figure~\ref{LCFigure:snapshot}(b) demonstrates formation of a
276 + chevron structure. The first peak of the radial distribution
277 + function $g(r)$ in Fig.~\ref{LCFigure:gofrz}(a) shows that the
278 + minimum distance for two in plane banana shaped molecules is 4.9
279 + \AA, while the second split peak implies the biaxial packing. It is
280 + also important to show the density correlation along the director
281 + which is given by :
282 + \begin{equation}
283 + g(z) =\frac{1}{\pi R^{2} \rho}< \delta (z-z_{ij})>_{ij},
284 + \end{equation}
285 + where $ z_{ij}  = r_{ij}  \cdot \hat Z $ was measured in the
286 + director frame and $R$ is the radius of the cylindrical sampling
287 + region. The oscillation in density plot along the director in
288 + Fig.~\ref{LCFigure:gofrz}(b) implies the existence of the layered
289 + structure, and the peak at 27 $\rm{\AA}$ is attributed to a defect in the
290 + system.
291 +
292 + \subsection{Rotational Invariants}
293 +
294 + As a useful set of correlation functions to describe
295 + position-orientation correlation, rotation invariants were first
296 + applied in a spherical symmetric system to study x-ray and light
297 + scatting\cite{Blum1972}. Latterly, expansion of the orientation pair
298 + correlation in terms of rotation invariant for molecules of
299 + arbitrary shape has been introduced by Stone\cite{Stone1978} and
300 + adopted by other researchers in liquid crystal
301 + studies\cite{Berardi2003}. In order to study the correlation between
302 + biaxiality and molecular separation distance $r$, we calculate a
303 + rotational invariant function $S_{22}^{220} (r)$, which is given by
304 + :
305 + \begin{eqnarray}
306 + S_{22}^{220} (r) & = & \frac{1}{{4\sqrt 5 }} \left< \delta (r -
307 + r_{ij} )((\hat x_i  \cdot \hat x_j )^2  - (\hat x_i  \cdot \hat y_j
308 + )^2  - (\hat y_i  \cdot \hat x_j )^2  + (\hat y_i  \cdot \hat y_j
309 + )^2 ) \right. \notag \\
310 + & & \left. - 2(\hat x_i  \cdot \hat y_j )(\hat y_i \cdot \hat x_j ) -
311 + 2(\hat x_i  \cdot \hat x_j )(\hat y_i  \cdot \hat y_j )) \right>.
312 + \end{eqnarray}
313 + The long range behavior of second rank orientational correlation
314 + $S_{22}^{220} (r)$ in Fig~\ref{LCFigure:S22220} also confirm the
315 + biaxiality of the system.
316 +
317   \begin{figure}
318   \centering
319 < \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{bananGB_grained.eps}
320 < \caption[]{} \label{LCFigure:BananaGB}
319 > \includegraphics[width=4.5in]{snapshot.eps}
320 > \caption[Snapshot of the molecular organization in the layered phase
321 > formed at temperature T = 460K and pressure P = 1 atm]{Snapshot of
322 > the molecular organization in the layered phase formed at
323 > temperature T = 460K and pressure P = 1 atm. (a) diagonal view; (b)
324 > side view.} \label{LCFigure:snapshot}
325   \end{figure}
326  
327   \begin{figure}
328   \centering
329 < \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{gb_scheme.eps}
330 < \caption[]{Schematic diagram showing definitions of the orientation
331 < vectors for a pair of Gay-Berne molecules}
332 < \label{LCFigure:GBScheme}
329 > \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{gofr_gofz.eps}
330 > \caption[Correlation Functions of a Bent-core Liquid Crystal System
331 > at Temperature T = 460K and Pressure P = 10 atm]{Correlation
332 > Functions of a Bent-core Liquid Crystal System at Temperature T =
333 > 460K and Pressure P = 10 atm. (a) radial correlation function
334 > $g(r)$; and (b) density along the director $g(z)$.}
335 > \label{LCFigure:gofrz}
336   \end{figure}
337  
338 < \section{\label{liquidCrystalSection:methods}Methods}
338 > \begin{figure}
339 > \centering
340 > \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{s22_220.eps}
341 > \caption[Average orientational correlation Correlation Functions of
342 > a Bent-core Liquid Crystal System at Temperature T = 460K and
343 > Pressure P = 10 atm]{Average orientational correlation Correlation
344 > Functions of a Bent-core Liquid Crystal System at Temperature T =
345 > 460K and Pressure P = 10 atm.} \label{LCFigure:S22220}
346 > \end{figure}
347  
348 < \section{\label{liquidCrystalSection:resultDiscussion}Results and Discussion}
348 > \section{Conclusion}
349 >
350 > We have presented a simple dipolar three-site GB model for banana
351 > shaped molecules which are capable of forming smectic phases from
352 > isotropic configuration. Various order parameters and correlation
353 > functions were used to characterized the structural properties of
354 > these smectic phase. However, the forming layered structure still
355 > had some defects because of the mismatching between the layer
356 > structure spacing and the shape of simulation box. This mismatching
357 > can be broken by using NPTf integrator in further simulations. The
358 > role of terminal chain in controlling transition temperatures and
359 > the type of mesophase formed have been studied
360 > extensively\cite{Pelzl1999}. The lack of flexibility in our model
361 > due to the missing terminal chains could explain the fact that we
362 > did not find evidence of chirality.

Diff Legend

Removed lines
+ Added lines
< Changed lines
> Changed lines